Reviews
for Conversations on Ethics, Oxford University
Press (hardback
2009;
Kindle 2010;
paperback 2011).
The dialogue is always insightful. (...)
The interviewees turn out to be genuine philosophers, diligent and
enormously intelligent but nonetheless struggling and fallible. The
value of Voorhoeve's book is that it shows how great minds come to their
ideas and come to disagree on fundamental issues. (...) I can recommend
it to anyone who wants to delve deeper into ethics.
Bart Engelen,
Ethical Perspectives 17 (2010): 680-3. Full review
here.
[A] delight, both in conception and
in execution. (...) Voorhoeve's engagement with each thinker is
informed, precise, clear, and insightful. Each interview is a
pleasure to read. I can highly recommend Conversations on Ethics
as worthwhile for anyone interested in ethics.
Lauren
Tillinghast, Philosophical Practice 5 (2010): 712-3.
Full review
here.
Probes
positions in a precise and clear way. (...) The conversational
form is refreshing when compared with other textual forms, like
the monograph. (...) Not only does it provide readers with the outline
of each interviewee's position, but it also offers a personal impression
of each thinker. (...) Exciting.
Uta Bittner,
Zeitschrift fuer
medizinische Ethik 56 [4] (2010): 376-8 Full review
here.
Voorhoeve has a real gift for detecting
the vulnerable parts in any thinker's argumentation and exposing them in
a manner that forces the philosopher to produce a more comprehensive
account of her or his views. (...) [A]n excellent illustration of the
two desiderata that have inspired philosophical inquiry since the time
of Socrates: (...) a special ability for critical thinking [and] a
demand for honesty and authenticity.
Cristian Iftode,
Public Reason 2 (2010): 96-100. Full review
here.
Accessible and even potentially
thrilling for the non specialist. (...) Voorhoeve excels in many
conversations at probing the ideas of his interlocutor. (...) A great
contribution to the field.
Francois Claveau, Ethics & Economics
7
(2010). Full review
here.
Richly instructive and delightful to
read. Voorhoeve has a sophisticated command of his interlocutors'
philosophical views, and his questions often hit the nail on the head.
(...) The conversational method, with its unique ability to dwell on the
more obscure or vulnerable junctions of a philosophical view, helps
deepen our understanding of what is sometimes hidden between the lines
of systematic texts. (...) [I}t provides the most valuable
insights on the nature of ethics.
Shlomo Cohen,
Iyyun: The Jerusalem Philosophical Quarterly 59
(2010): 63-77. Full review
here.
Nietzsche said that all great problems
demand great love. (...) Nietzsche was a hard man to please. But he
would have felt some satisfaction with Voorhoeve's eleven interviews.
His philosophers fight for their theories, defending them ferociously
and lovingly. (...) Almost always, one falls in with their
reasoning--at least, this is what happened to me. But, of course, this
leads to inconsistency. For the difference in their views is far too
great. This is bewildering, and teaches us a good lesson: not to be
unmovable in one's attachments to one's moral views. (...) It shows just
how difficult moral calculation and justification of one's views to
others is.
Jan Greven,
Trouw (a Dutch daily newspaper,
2010; click
here for the full article; translation mine.)
Intellectually stimulating and highly
entertaining (...) Voorhoeve has a knack for teasing out
revealing answers. His probing questions often bring out the
weakest or most revealing parts of the interviewed philosophers' views
(...) Exciting.
Krister Bykvist, The Philosophers' Magazine
49 (2010): 110-1. Full review
here.
[A]
beautifully produced collection. (...) A pleasure to read as well as
philosophically valuable. Overall, it is an excellent book, providing
something different, involving and very welcome.
Hugh Upton,
Philosophical Investigations 33 (2010): 380-3. Full
review
here.
A superb collection of interviews with leading
figures in moral philosophy: Voorhoeve deftly limns the broad outlines of their
thought and paints a physical picture of the setting, before interrogating his
subjects' theories. (...) [A]n exemplary demonstration of
philosophical discussion in action.
Steven Poole, The Guardian (6
February 2010). Full review
here.
This book beautifully refutes the idea
that engaging with philosophical questions is difficult and tiring.
Uta Bittner & Tobias Eichinger,
Philosophisches Jahrbuch 118 (2011): 161-5. Full review
here; translation mine.
I have rarely enjoyed a philosophy book
as much. Voorhoeve's bold effort really works. He cunningly brings
ethical theory to life through insightful conversations with key
philosophers and scientists. Not only do the issues come alive, but the
participants do as well. Don't miss the chance to eavesdrop on these
conversations.
Norman Daniels, Harvard University
Voorhoeve has interviewed many of the
most interesting and influential recent thinkers on ethical topics,
expertly focusing on their core positions and arguments in a series of
insightful philosophical dialogues. In doing so he has produced not only
a comprehensive introduction to contemporary ethical thought, but also a
real sense of the human beings behind the writings.
Jonathan Wolff, University College London
Information on an evening on the
book at the
Harvard Humanities Center.
Reported in the
Harvard Crimson.
An evening on the book at philosophical
cafe
Felix & Sofie (Amsterdam); on their
books of the month list for November 2009.