p

q

r

Consistent relative to legal doctrine?

Individual 1

(True)

(True)

True

a

Individual 2

(True)

(False)

False

a

Individual 3

(False)

(True)

False

a

Concl.-based

-

-

False

(a)

4 Propositionwise majority voting

4 Premise-based procedure (issue-by-issue voting)

4 Conclusion-based procedure (case-by-case voting)