A. Questions for Submission
2.1 Atoms and Diffusion
- State the atomic hypothesis and contrast it with the continuum view of matter.
- In what sense does a description of randomly walking atoms give rise to the prediction of diffusion?
2.2. Models and fictions
Does the random walk model of diffusion pose a difficulty for the structuralist (semantic) account of models? Why or why not? What alternatives do you see?
2.3. Randomly walking atoms in action
- Explain Einstein's model of sugar molecules in water, and what it led him to conclude about the size and number of the sugar molecules.
- Name an idealisation that this model introduced. Why is this idealisation needed, and why might you expect the model to be successful in spite of it?
Further Discussion (Optional)
- Describe Einstein's account of Brownian motion. How did it support the atomic hypothesis?
- Name an idealisation introduced in Einstein's description of Brownian motion. (There are many.) Is this idealisation different in kind from the one above? Why or why not?